According to the State Statistics Service, as of January 1, 2017, there are 15 206 join-stock companies registered in Ukraine, 3 122 of which are the public companies. Although the Ukrainian independence celebrates its 25- year anniversary already, only recently the national business has started to review the governance system and the system of effective implementation of global corporate governance practices. However, in Ukraine, this phenomenon is so young that not everyone understands that the creation of corporations is not the same as the formation of an effective corporate governance system.
Corporate governance is a system of rules, methods, and procedures defining the company’s management and the system of relations between all the interested parties. Achievement of an optimal balance of interests of all stakeholders, viz. shareholders, managers, customers, suppliers, financiers, government, and society, should be the aim of good corporate governance. It covers almost all spheres, i.e. from the action plans and internal management to assessment of the production or disclosure effectiveness. Standards of the system demonstrate the company’s efficiency and prospects and hence its potential in the related market to investors and the public. However, unbalanced system or incorrect risk assessment lead to inefficient operation of the company or reduce a period of its effective operating, prosperity etc.
How did the corporate governance originate?
History of the Ukrainian corporatization divides into two stages, i.e. the pre-Soviet and the post-Soviet periods. Large and highly efficient corporate enterprises and many small but proficient companies operated at the end of XIX in the first decade of XX century in the biggest cities of Ukraine constituting a part of the Russian Empire. By the level of industrial production concentration, Ukraine occupied one of the leading places in the world. Over 44 % of all workers were employed at big enterprises (whereas in the USA – 33 %). This situation contributed to the monopolization process, which had started in some sectors of the domestic economy.
Mighty syndicates had immense production capacities. For example, Produhol, one of such syndicates, founded in 1904, embodied 18 joint-stock companies and controlled 75 % of coal production in the Donetsk Basin. However, precisely a century ago, notorious events that shook the Empire have frozen the history of Ukrainian corporatization for many years. A significant number of
the enterprises was liquidated and their properties were nationalized. Only joint-stock companies experiencing state’s involvement and being under state’s tight control managed to remain at least in the field of foreign economic activities. The last attempt to form a joint-stock relation in the public sector has been carried out by the issuance of shares of the workforce and the company’s shares as it provided for by the decree of the USSR Council of Ministers «On the issue of securities by enterprises and organizations in October 1988». Given that such issue didn’t become widespread, in 1992 it was abolished.
Formation of a new history
The recent history of corporate governance began with Ukraine’s independence and the adoption of the Law of Ukraine «On Business Associations». The Law defined a joint stock company as an independent entity and defined legal basis of its institution and functioning. But corporate relations introduced at those times were utterly imperfect: deprivation of minority shareholders of their
rights, schemes of reorganization from OJSC into CJSC depending on interests of corporate managers, multiple registers of shareholders and raider attacks. Corporatization of the privatized enterprises that lasted for many years and proved to be fairly low efficient was another major issue. In 2008, with the adoption of the Law of Ukraine «On Joint Stock Companies», a new stage in the history of domestic production corporatization has started. This regulatory act became the result of the struggle, diligence and extraordinary efforts of a wide range of professionals, including international ones.
A study of corporate governance system, conducted by KPMG in September 2013 showed that more or less effectively formed corporate governance system actually began to appear even before the law adoption – in 2005. Upon the adoption, a number of companies using such tools raised tenfold. In addition, in 2014 the National Securities and Stock Market Commission approved a new version of the strategically important document, i.e. Principles of Corporate Governance. It has not only systematized the status and mechanisms of corporate governance provisions implementation but also has summarized the global trends in this sphere, as it was constituted on the basis of the OECD Principles of Corporate Governance. It is generally accepted that this document summarizes the global vision of all the components of effective corporate governance.
However, despite the adoption of a fairly broad regulatory framework, many problems are still to be resolved. In general, corporate governance remains at a fairly low level. The most important issues and challenges to be improved include:
Practical implementation of the system
As far as practical implementation of corporate governance is concerned, the research by the rating agency «IBI-Rating» as of March-April 2016 studying Ukrainian commercial banks can cast light on the situation in Ukraine. It showed (based on 11 study subjects), that generally increase in regulatory requirements contributed to the improvement of corporate governance in the banking system. Despite this, not all banks implement advanced principles of corporate governance, many of them perform only mandatory legal requirements in this sphere, and recommendations and international experience are embodied by few and yet partially. It was found that an average level of banks’ compliance with international and Ukrainian progressive principles of corporate governance and experience of innovation implementation in this field is quite low, what points out to a significant risk for the shareholders, investors, and stakeholders.
In general, the positive is that the percentage of companies that have successfully implemented corporate governance system is steadily increasing. Even before defining the position of Corporate Secretary/Director as a mandatory one, such provision was introduced by many companies. In 2016, the rating agency IBI-Rating analyzed corporate governance showings of 55 companies with shares traded on the international and Ukrainian stock exchanges: 12 companies with shares traded on international stock exchanges, and 43 companies with shares traded on the Ukrainian stock exchanges. Based on the study, companies’ ratings based on the corporate governance level were defined.
Top five rated companies with shares traded on international markets include «Astarta Holding N.V», «Kernel Holding S.A.», «Industrial Milk Company», «Ovostar Union», and «Cadogan Petroleum».
The top five of the companies with shares traded on the Ukrainian platforms consists of «Ukrtelecom», «Concern Halnaftohaz», «Farmak», «Kyivenerho», and «Centrenerho».
At present, the state lobbies the Law «On corporate governance», which is to reform and de facto to introduce a system of good corporate governance at state enterprises of all types. In addition, the adoption in the first reading of two bills concerning the corporate governance reform was an important innovation. The first bill on the squeeze-out and sell-out mechanisms will allow jointstock companies to reduce costs related to the publicity requirements, reduce the reporting volumes, loosen regulation, get more possibilities to protect themselves from raiding and reduce the threat of corporate blackmail. By virtue of the bill, without additional costs for correspondence with the company and opening a securities account the minority shareholders will have the possibility to apply the sell-out procedure, receive a market price for their securities and leave the company as shareholders. The second bill will improve the mechanisms of corporate governance, provide flexibility in structuring the relations of the issuer and the investor, contribute to a safer investment, etc. Each investor will have the assurance that at any time they could leave the business, take their investment and due dividends.
LDaily decided to conduct a survey among the companies working in Ukraine to find out what social projects they support and why. Anastasia Voitkevych, Head of Corporate Communications & Social Responsibility, Winner Group Ukraine Winner CSR has two focus areas — Charity and Responsible Business. Charity is philanthropy, Winner’s and its leadership’s […]
The largest European countries are going to exit quarantine. On Monday, Germany, the Czech Republic, France, Poland, Norway and Denmark are lifting some of the quarantine restrictions imposed to combat the coronavirus epidemic. So, in Germany, it was allowed to open commercial space less than 800 square meters in size. Car dealers and bookstores were […]
In the context of large-scale reformatting of the banking sector in Ukraine, many surviving banks declare responsiveness to credit requests. The experts admit that it is the right time to increase it. Last year the National Bank of Ukraine (NBU) reported a steady decline in total loans however business needs to be pushed to develop […]
A staff lawyer or a freelance consultant? This question was asked by many businesses, if not by all. And any of the control of management found both pluses and minuses of each option. Some people prefer in-house lawyers (corporate – in house), because they know the situation “from within”, while others are trying to involve […]
The outgoing 2016 was hard, and not only for business but also for the country in general. It was really difficult but not fatal: a new tax policy, the integration into the European market, difficulties of investment and many other things. There are key factors which have affected the development of a business industry much […]
The victory of the candidate of republicans at presidential elections in the United States of America became a big surprise for the world community. Despite the fact that most the analytical bureaus holding authority on the USA relied on democrats, Donald Trump could collect 290 votes of delegates, therefore, became the forty-fifth President of America. […]
A Business, as well as any other sphere of professional activity, demands from the person a certain complex of knowledge, abilities and tendencies. In any case, if you actually plan to achieve stable success as the entrepreneur, the corresponding education will become some kind of catalyst in the course of achievement of this purpose. The […]
American video game company, Roblox Corporation, is working with the investment banks on the preparation for listing on the US stock exchange, which may happen early next year. According to the Reuters, such step should help Roblox to take advantage becoming popular during the pandemic. The company expects to be able to double its recent […]Next
The coronavirus epidemic in the world will intensify by the end of this year due to the seasonality of the infection, but in early 2021 the situation will improve. This opinion was expressed by the head of Microsoft Bill Gates at the virtual conference GeekWire Summit. This was reported by Inc. “The good news is […]Next
PIMCO and other investors appealed to the court with the case against Citigroup, due to the fact that the bank is not able to control the mortgage loans, resulting in $2.3 billion of losses. Citigroup will respond in a New York´s state court in Manhattan for actions that not justified the confidence of investors. Now […]Next
Mobile operator lifecell sold its sister company telecommunication towers in Ukraine. The Ukrtower Company will pay minimum $ 52 million plus taxes for 811 objects. This is stated in the message of the owner of the company – Turkish Turkcell Holding. According to the report, the resolution on the transaction was carried by the Turkish […]Next
Shares of Advanced Micro Devices, increased on 47.4% since the beginning of the year, rose on 10% after the announcement of the financial results of the 2nd quarter, which ended on June 27, and the publication of optimistic forecasts, despite the pandemic. The report was preceded by a sharp rise in shares of AMD after […]Next
At 27th of November, 2015 the famous American company REI, which sells products for sports, tourism and travel, reported that on Friday – 30th of November, all 143 stores will be closed. The company decided to arrange for their employees a paid for the output. This decision is a kind of protest against rampant consumerism. […]Next
Almost 100% of the shares (99.83%) of Kherson heat and power plant will be re-auctioned by the State Property Fund of Ukraine. According to preliminary data it will be held on March, 16 of this year on sale with a starting price of 155 million UAH. It is reported by the source Sehodnia.ua. Terms of […]Next
Recently, one of the plants of Lviv, which operates in the agricultural sector, has become bankrupt. This refers to the agricultural machinery plant “Lvovselmash” that the Commercial Court of Zaporizhia region declared a bankrupt and opened the liquidation procedure. Last month, in February, the Commercial Court of Zaporizhia region ordered the reopening of the bankruptcy […]Next
From confidence to clarity, there are a number of reasons holding you back from success. Previously LDaily wrote about how important it is to improve the professional value – “To be successful in business means to have a high” social currency “, take into account the things that you need to pay attention to at […]Next
Recently there were closed the deal on the absorption by the Intel Developer Altera company. In a statement to journalists the head of the Intel, said that Altera is now an integral part of the company and will operate as a division. In a statement, Intel spokesman also said that Altera will now be called […]Next
During the past 5 years was invested about $ 10 million per year in the construction and modernization of the elevators of “Agroprosperis”. This was told by the CEO of the NCH Agribusiness Investment Fund – “Agroprosperis” Group of companies, Igor Osmachko in an interview to the Liga.Business. “For the moment, the structure of the […]Next
According to informed sources, the Antimonopoly Committee has fined the Dnepropetrivsk pharmacy for consumer fraud. The fine for the violation of unfair anti-competition law amounted to 68 thousand UAH. The Dnipropetrivsk regional territorial office of the AMCU asked the “Pharmacy №338”, LLC (Dnepropetrivsk) to pay the fine as soon as possible. This was said on […]Next
In 2019, Ukraine and Austria hold the Bilateral Cultural Year. Its official opening and the launch of the website austriaukraine2019.com took place on 22 February in Kyiv. The ceremony and the reception were attended by diplomats and cultural influencers of both countries. The Bilateral Cultural Year in Ukraine was inaugurated by Ambassador Extraordinary and Plenipotentiary […]Next
According to the Wall street journal, the French regulatory authority has fined 20 firms engaged in the delivery for 672 million euro. The reason for this decision of regulators is financial fraud of companies, that administered prices through collusion for six years. The companies violated the law in the financial sector and in the field […]Next
According to the source Inventure, Ukraine has attracted nearly $ 4 billion ($ 3.8 billion) of foreign investment over the past 2016. This figure exceeds the amount of 2015 almost doubly. These indicators were noted by First Vice Prime Minister of Ukraine Stepan Kubiv at the governmental seminar “The economic development of the regions: strategies […]Next
Each company and the man himself admits, sometimes failing, seemingly mistakes. But if it is really a failure or a good experience for the development shows a wonderful book of Laurence G. Weinzimmer and Jim McConoughey “The Wisdom of Failure”. 5 small stories from the book will help you to understand that the business mistakes […]Next