Judge Finds 1977 Egyptian Pact Is Not Valid for 2015 US Divorce

Judge Finds 1977 Egyptian Pact Is Not Valid for 2015 US Divorce

16.09.2015 News

A New York judge has determined that an Islamic marriage contract entered into during a 1977 wedding ceremony in Egypt is not binding on the court’s consideration of the couple’s divorce now.

While Westchester County Supreme Court Justice Lawrence Ecker said New York courts have recognized that the marriage contract, called a “mahr,” can be enforceable, Ecker wrote in O.Y. v. A.G. that the document must be accompanied by proof of authentication in order to be valid under New York Real Property Law §301 and Domestic Relations Law §236.

Ecker said the mahr in question has not been subscribed nor acknowledged by the wife. Since the husband did not otherwise present authentication by a method approved by the Hague Convention of 1961, Ecker said he would not recognize the marriage contract as valid.

In any event, Ecker said, since the mahr in question is worth a total of $131 for the wife in event of the husband’s death or the dissolution of their marriage, it is in the best interests of all the parties to eliminate it as a consideration at this point in the couple’s current divorce proceedings in New York.

“Given the de minimis benefit to have been conferred upon plaintiff (the wife), there is no reason for the parties’ resources, or the court’s time, to be further expended in attempting to prove the validity of the mahr in question by expert testimony or otherwise, as suggested by the defendant,” Ecker wrote from White Plains. “Accordingly, the court finds that the mahr now under consideration is not enforceable in New York.”

Ecker granted the wife’s motion and dismissed the husband’s affirmative defense in relation to the mahr pursuant to CPLR 3211(b). He also ruled that the wife is estopped from seeking recovery of the $131.

The husband, “A.G.,” had argued that the mahr should govern the settlement the couple is now trying to reach before Ecker in a divorce action filed by the wife, “O.Y.”, on Aug. 11, 2014.

The husband cited to Avitzur v. Avitzur, 58 NY2d 108 (1983) for that contention. In Avitzur, the Court of Appeals upheld the enforceability of the secular terms of a “Ketubah” agreement between a man and wife entered into as part of a Jewish religious marriage ceremony.

Like the Ketubah, the mahr spells out a groom’s responsibilities toward the wife. In the O.Y. v. A.G. marriage, the husband signed the mahr, and the wife acquiesced through the signature of her uncle, according to Muslim tradition. She did not sign the mahr herself during the Islamic wedding ceremony on July 28, 1977, in Zagazig, Egypt, according to Ecker’s ruling.

Ecker also rejected the husband’s argument that a postnuptial agreement the couple signed in 2013 relieves the husband of further financial responsibilities the wife is seeking in her 2014 divorce filing. Ecker said the 2013 agreement should be looked at, not as an opt-out agreement binding the parties in a future divorce proceeding, but as signed in settlement for the wife’s agreement to discontinue without prejudice a 2012 divorce filing she made.

Ecker said the divorce action under the wife’s 2014 filing will proceed with the customary consideration of the principles of maintenance, equitable distribution, attorney fees and the other factors that are at play in the dissolution of a marriage in New York. The judge said he accepted the husband’s argument that any considerations that flowed to the wife under the 2013 postnuptial agreement should be weighed by the judge in working out the equitable distribution of the couple’s assets.

The judge ordered the parties to return to his court on Sept. 24.

Ecker said he did not have enough information to pass judgment on the distribution of marital property in the husband’s name in Egypt. The judge noted that the husband questioned whether an Egyptian court would honor the distribution of Egyptian property as ordered by a New York court in a divorce decree.

Ecker said he wanted time to get more information from the parties on the precise Egyptian property holdings and to consider “alternative dispositions” of the couple’s assets “to do justice to each of the parties.”

Howard Pobiner of White Plains represented the husband.

Pobiner said Ecker was “well within” his authority when finding that neither the mahr nor the 2013 postnuptial agreement were “opt outs” of the divorce decree that Ecker is trying to formulate.

Pobiner said “prevailing case law” around the country has been coming to the consensus that a mahr with the type of money called for in the case of O.Y. and A.G. represents an “unconscionably low” settlement by the standards of American customs and equitable distribution laws.

The wife’s attorney, Neveen Nesheiwat of Yonkers, praised Ecker for making a nuanced analysis of the mahr and determining that the one for O.Y.-A.G. is not valid for purposes of the couple’s divorce in 2015.

“Many lawyers are using it [the mahr] to curtail equitable rights and equitable distributions of assets,” Nesheiwat said in an interview Friday. “They are putting mostly women at risk.”

Nesheiwat said Ecker’s ruling will create case law in New York on the side of women who are unfairly disadvantaged by applications of Islamic Law outside of the Middle East.

She said it was also significant that Ecker announced his intention to try to draw any property holdings that the couple may have in Egypt into the New York divorce settlement because U.S. courts have tended “not to address those assets in light of the fact that those foreign nations do not give full faith and credit to American court directives.”

“Women tend to lose interests in those properties abroad,” she said.

Nesheiwat characterized the couple’s assets as being in excess of $1 million. She said the couple had children, but they are all emancipated.

Other articles

Read also

Judge Finds 1977 Egyptian Pact Is Not Valid for 2015 US Divorce
News

Credit Agricole will pay the US government $ 99 million for aiding citizens in tax evasion

Division of a major bank in Switzerland will pay to the USA government a fine of   $ 99 million to settle the case to the complicity of American citizens in tax evasion, – reports The Wall Street Journal. In its defense, the bank’s representatives said that their establishment has never been support those who […]

Next
Judge Finds 1977 Egyptian Pact Is Not Valid for 2015 US Divorce
News

The new Ukrainian airline has registered two aircraft

The new Ukrainian low-cost carrier Bees Airline registered its first two aircraft in Ukraine – a Boeing 737-800. “This is a Boeing 737-800 with flight numbers of the Ukrainian register UR-UBA and UR-UBB. The State Aviation Service issued registration certificates for them on February 22 and 23, 2021,” the statement reads. It is noted that […]

Next
Judge Finds 1977 Egyptian Pact Is Not Valid for 2015 US Divorce
News

The WHO hopes to radically change the situation with the coronavirus by March

The World Health Organization expects that by the spring of 2021, the situation in the fight against the coronavirus pandemic could change significantly. The main hope is the invention of vaccine against the disease. This was stated by Adviser to the Director-General of the WHO Bruce Aylward. He noted that by March the situation could […]

Next
Judge Finds 1977 Egyptian Pact Is Not Valid for 2015 US Divorce
News

Нappy New Year!

Editorial office of business publication LDaily wishes all a Happy New Year! We sincerely wish you to meet the 2017 th with a smile and a warm heart. Let the coming year will give us all another opportunity to finish the job, or start with a clean sheet – write a different story, in which […]

Next
Judge Finds 1977 Egyptian Pact Is Not Valid for 2015 US Divorce
News

Belarus to reduce gasoline exports to Ukraine

The Belarusian oil company will reduce the supply of A-95 gasoline to Ukraine in June by more than five times – up to 10 thousand tons. This was reported by enkorr citing a source. It is noted that the decision was made after the news of the BNC’s intention to reset the supply of this […]

Next
Judge Finds 1977 Egyptian Pact Is Not Valid for 2015 US Divorce
News

For the first time in Ukraine, a list of critical infrastructure banks has been compiled

For the first time, the National Bank has identified a list of critical infrastructure facilities in the banking system of Ukraine. This was reported on the regulator’s website on Friday, April 23. It is noted that such powers of the NBU are provided by the Law on Basic Principles of Cyber ​​Security of Ukraine. “Objects […]

Next
Judge Finds 1977 Egyptian Pact Is Not Valid for 2015 US Divorce
News

Three suspicions were signed in the case of PrivatBank

Prosecutor General Iryna Venediktova has reconciled three suspicions with former officials of PrivatBank, the press service of the Prosecutor General’s Office reports. Thus, the notification on the change of the previously reported suspicion to the former chairman of the bank’s board, the former deputy chairman of the board and the former head of the interbank […]

Next
Judge Finds 1977 Egyptian Pact Is Not Valid for 2015 US Divorce
News

Naftogaz announced a sharp increase in profits

Naftogaz states that in the first quarter of 2021 they received a net profit of UAH 12.6 billion against UAH 3.2 billion a year earlier. The group’s CFO Petrus van Drill said so. “I am pleased to announce that the net profit in the first quarter of 2021 is UAH 12.6 billion (unaudited preliminary result, […]

Next
Judge Finds 1977 Egyptian Pact Is Not Valid for 2015 US Divorce
News

Pfizer has merged with Allergan to avoid the “non-competitive tax rates.”

A few days ago between two companies was signed an agreement for $ 150 billion. It was the merger of two large companies – manufacturer of drugs and vaccines Pfizer and Allergan, which producing cosmetics and botox. The deal was struck not only to consolidate or improve its production system. The main reason for the […]

Next
Judge Finds 1977 Egyptian Pact Is Not Valid for 2015 US Divorce
News

Apple has postponed the release of MacBook and iPad due to lack of chips and displays

Apple has been forced to postpone the release of some MacBook laptops and iPads due to a shortage of components. This was reported by Nikkei Asia with reference to informed sources. According to them, the problems with the production of MacBook are due to the global shortage of chips. Automakers have been suffering from a […]

Next
Judge Finds 1977 Egyptian Pact Is Not Valid for 2015 US Divorce
News

Centerenergo has paid UAH 500 million a month to the mines

Centerenergo has paid more than 475 million hryvnias to the mines since the beginning of the month and has no debts, according to the company’s website. As you know, Centerenergo – the only consumer of coal from state-owned mines, buys almost the entire volume of their production under direct contracts. “However, the current purchase price […]

Next
Judge Finds 1977 Egyptian Pact Is Not Valid for 2015 US Divorce
News

The tourism industry will lose 120 million jobs

The global tourism industry could lose 120 million jobs due to the COVID-19 coronavirus pandemic. This was stated in a video message by UN General Secretary Antonio Guterres. According to him, tourism has become one of the sectors most affected by the pandemic, and no country has been unaffected by the sharp decline in international […]

Next
Judge Finds 1977 Egyptian Pact Is Not Valid for 2015 US Divorce
News

Ukraine has assessed the potential for hydrogen production

Ukraine can produce an average of about 5.5 billion cubic meters of “green” hydrogen annually. This was announced on Monday, March 29, by the State Agency for Energy Efficiency. Experts of the United Nations Economic Commission for Europe with the support of the Ministry of Energy and the State Agency conducted studies of the potential […]

Next
Judge Finds 1977 Egyptian Pact Is Not Valid for 2015 US Divorce
News

Major oil company Total was fined for $ 3.6 million

Commodity Futures Trading Commission USA announced the application of penalties in respect of the American division of the oil company Total. The company is accused of fraud in the gas market in the USA, in an attempt to carry out manipulations with the index monthly gas prices in Houston and other markets in the United […]

Next
Judge Finds 1977 Egyptian Pact Is Not Valid for 2015 US Divorce
News

Panasonic invests $ 1.6 billion in the construction of the Tesla Gigafactory plant

Major Japanese manufacturer  Panasonic announced that it would invest $ 1.6 billion in the construction of the Tesla Gigafactory plant. As the company reported on its website, such an investment  is motivated by the fact that Panasonic shares the aims and objectives of the American automaker, and therefore wants to support its activities. Analysts argue […]

Next
WP2Social Auto Publish Powered By : XYZScripts.com