Investment in Ukraine: inevitable or impossible?

Investment in Ukraine: inevitable or impossible?

17.02.2020 Analytics

INTENDED POTENTIAL

Each country possesses certain positive qualities that enable it to compete for investment when attracting foreign capital. These can be natural resources, geopolitical features, the legal system, level of production, technological and cultural development, etc.

Since Ukraine has declared its independence, a certain rating of its investment attractiveness potential has also emerged.

Land takes the first place in this rating. Ukraine is one of the largest European countries with an area exceeding
600,000 km2 (almost 6% of Europe) with a land fund of over 60 million hectares. Agricultural land is about 19% of allEuropean farmland, including arable land — about 27%. The area of agricultural land is 42.7 million hectares (more than 70% of the territory of the country), and arable land is 32.5 million hectares (78.4% of all agricultural land). Forests make up 17.6% of the country, water areas — 4.0%. Per capita farmland is the highest among European countries. It amounts to 0.9 hectares, including 0.7 hectares of arable land (the average level in European countries is 0.44/0.25 hectares, respectively). A particular difference is black earth or chernozem. According to various scientific sources, its area ranges from 15.6 million to 17.4 million hectares (about 8% of world reserves).

The geopolitical position has traditionally and historically been the second most important indicator of the economic attractiveness of the country. From ancient times, large trade routes passed through the territory of Ukraine. Even in the times of Kievan Rus, there was the “route from the Varangians to the Greeks” (linking the Scandinavian countries with the Byzantine Empire) and the northern branch of the Great Silk Road.

There also was a route through Kyiv from the countries of Western Europe to the east, to the region of the Caspian Sea. The topic of forming a new-format Silk Road, which implies the participation of Ukraine, is being actively discussed now. In June 2015, the Chinese Ambassador to Ukraine Zhang Xiun stated that China is ready to invest in Ukrainian infrastructure to implement the New Silk Road initiative. Ukraine shares borders with seven countries, including two with maritime and land neighborhood, and also has a direct sea outlet to Turkey. Noteworthy, the country’s location provides economic advantages, especially in the development of logistics.

The industrial and technological level occupies the third place in the rating and has historical roots. In the times of the USSR, quite a powerful production and technological potential were formed in Ukraine. Much has been lost in the new economic environment after the collapse of the Soviet Union. Still, some industries have recovered and are
developing. In particular, this is fair about aviation, chemical and mining industries, some units of the machine building industry, and others. The industrial sector needs replenishment with highly qualified personnel, which in turn contributes to the existence and development of the scientific and technological sphere of the country. That is why the scientific and educational base has the fourth position among all the factors of the investment attractiveness of Ukraine. This base includes an extensive network of research institutes, laboratories, experimental facilities, and a good educational level of specialists in universities, which makes them competitive in world markets (such as IT). It also includes a rather high proportion of scientists (Ph.D.’s) and students — potential technicians and managers.

Among other factors of investment attractiveness are climatic conditions, minerals, and some other points. There are even purely cultural and social things: commitment to democratic European values, national traditions, historical belonging to Europe, and a desire to join the EU…

All this drives the following thought: What foreign capital would refuse to work in such a country?

REALITIES

However, investment reality is far from high hopes. For more than 10 years, FDI in Ukraine has been fluctuating within $1-3 billion, with a single peak for 2007-2008 (see Table 1).

We must mention that the main world investor — the USA — is on the 14th place in Ukraine (as of 2019) with the $537 million total volume of FDI. The Russian Federation is ranked first (in 2018 — 27.8% of total investments, banks capitalization) and next comes… Cyprus (19.5%). This is a clear indicator of Round tripping investments — Ukrainian business takes out the money and then returns it to the country as ‘investments’ (so, the ultimate controlling investor is a resident thyself). According to the NBU, the volume of such FDI of domestic origin was about $500 million in 2018, and the share of Ukrainian money in total FDI was over 20.6%. Over the past eight years, these investments have reached the level of $8.4 billion, with the most significant inflows in 2010- 2013 (about one-third of total FDI). Such operations are mainly carried out through Cyprus, as well as Austria, the Netherlands and Switzerland. According to the Ministry of Finance, the lion’s share of FDI in Ukraine is returned from offshore zones and capitalization of banks. Thus, returning the capital of domestic business rather than the inflow of purely foreign capital into the development of the Ukrainian economy is practiced.

Anyway, for a European country with a population of over 42 million, these are minor amounts. For comparison, Poland with a population of about 38 million has FDI of almost 10 times higher than in Ukraine. At the same time, Polish FDI has significantly increased — almost 1.5 times — in the timeframe from 2004 (joining the EU) to 2008 (the global financial crisis). This contributed to the quality growth of exports: it rose 1.6 times by the end of 2013 (compared to 2008), which exceeded the growth of imports (1.5 times).

As for non-resident equity, only $1.71 billion (according to other data — $2.476 billion) came to Ukraine in 2018 (January-October), but $491.5 million was gone. The largest investors of this period were Germany ($141,8 million), the United Kingdom ($103.5 million), and by a landslide — the Netherlands ($57.7 million) and Poland ($41.5 million). For comparison, FDI in Poland in 2018 amounted to more than $12 billion…

As for the investment market volume, financial transfers of Ukrainian labor migrants are more than impressive. In the first half of 2019, they sent home $5.5 billion, which is by $254 million more than the figure for the same period last year. By the way, this increase indicates about 50 thousand new employable citizens of Ukraine who went to work abroad (we assume that one labor migrant transfers $1 thousand). The loss of this work potential puts an additional strain on the social sphere and the entire country’s economy, reducing its professional and human resources.

CONTROVERSIAL POPULARITY

According to the State Statistics, the largest investments in the first half of 2019 were directed to financial and insurance activities ($487.4 million), as well as to the industrial sector ($258.7 million). Further down are professional, scientific and technical activities ($140.3 million), real estate operations ($121.9 million).

Paradoxically, even though the mentioned-above agricultural land takes the first place in the rating of investment attractiveness of Ukraine only $59.6 million has been invested in agriculture, forestry and fisheries. The agricultural sector is the only sector able to attract big money to the country. It is the most popular one in the international investment environment in the long run. Still, there is one more condition for that — the opening of the land market. This is probably what Prime Minister O. Goncharuk is hoping for when promising to attract a $50-billion investment in the coming years.

However, when analyzing the public reaction to the lifting of the moratorium on land sales, as well as expert opinions, there are doubts about the reality of these plans. There is a titanic “battle” between the authorities and lay public for opening the land market. Time will tell who will be the winner, and now we will address the numbers. If we compare the average price of 1 hectare of leased land (around 4000 UAH — this amount is forecasted for opening the land market) and the average price for the sale of 1 hectare (around 20 thousand UAH), we will find that selling land is not profitable. Leasing is. We’ll calculate the simple difference between selling and long-term leasing land for 10 years (considering the cost per hectare). At the current prices, a landowner will receive 40 thousand UAH from leasing. They will continue adding 4 thousand UAH to this amount annually. A person who sells land will receive 20 thousand UAH one-time. If the state, for example, sells land for 1 billion UAH, it will be only a one-off profit. But if they lease, they will receive 1 billion UAH in 5 years and 2 billion UAH in 10 years while keeping the land as own property. There is a difference between instant and long-term benefits, and the second demonstrates the state’s approach to the land fund economy.

The argument that only the owner will be effective on the land is partly speculative. The country’s 49-year lease rate is almost an eternity under radical market transformations. If we return to the above calculations, we will see that the state will get tenfold income for leasing land compared to selling it (including control of its use).

EXPECTATIONS AND OPPORTUNITIES

The Cabinet of Ministers Chairman O. Goncharuk was discussing the recovery of the economic situation in the country and made a promise at a press briefing: “In the next five years (we consider this situation real and we set such an ambition), we will achieve a 40% economy increase. To do this, we need to raise $50 billion in investments.” Thus, to recover the economy and achieve GDP growth of 40% in the next 5 years, Ukraine must attract 10 billion of investments. There are statistics according to which GDP growth was 2.5% in the first quarter of 2019 and 4.6% in the second (compared to the same period in 2018). This exceeded the forecasts of the NBU and some foreign organizations for 2019 by up to 3%. However, according to the forecasts of the National Bank, GDP growth will be 3.2% in 2020, and 3.7% in 2021.

It is worth revisiting the numbers. According to the Prime Minister, if Ukraine’s GDP is going to increase by 40% by the end of 2024, its annual growth rate should be 8%. The numbers might not be even, they may be smaller sometimes. In 2020 and 2021, GDP growth will total 6.9% according to the NBU forecast. So, the next three years — 2022, 2023 and 2024 should give us 33.1%, which is slightly more than 11% annually. Is GDP growth by 11% real for Ukraine? According to statistics, in 2017, the global economy grew by 3.2% in general, and by the end of 2018, the growth was 3.0% on average.

We should mention the amount of expected investment as a necessary condition for GDP growth. In 2018, FDI in Ukraine was about $2.4 billion (see Table 1), and in the first half of 2019, it was $1.074 billion (see Table 2).

These volumes are clearly not sufficient to achieve the government’s planned economic impact. To accelerate economic growth, annual investment in Ukraine must exceed $10 billion. The Minister of Finance of Ukraine O. Markarova states: “If we now attract $1.5 billion, $2 billion, $3 billion in recent years, and $2.4 billion last year, this is not enough for the country and an economy like ours. Let’s say, this is completely invisible. These investments should include extra $10 billion.” Here’s one more comparison: the World Bank estimates that if Ukraine continues to keep its GDP growth at the level of 3%, it will take at least 50 years to catch up with Poland…

ISSUES, CAUSES AND SOLUTIONS

In the media and backrooms of power, the decrease in foreign investment in Ukraine has been directly linked to Russian aggression. Without any doubt, this is a significant factor, but is it decisive? If we analyze the “investment history” of Ukraine over 10-15 years (see Table 1), we can see that in 2014 (the period of social instability and the beginning of aggression of the Russian Federation), FDI sharply reduced to the level of 2002-2004 next year. In the years after 2014, despite the aggressive geopolitical environment, the country’s economy was able to survive and even began to show positive dynamics (GDP growth was outlined). The elections caused a decline in FDI in the first half of 2019 — investors are waiting and watching. However, such negative trends have been common for almost all previous periods of presidential or parliamentary elections. The new government is now creating a comfortable
environment for foreign capital. The fact that FDI was a bit over $1 billion in the first half of this year is not yet an economic reflection. However, the essence of their decrease is probably in politics. In this regard, it is worth noting that sharp fluctuations in FDI during periods of governmental changes indicate that business is highly dependent on
political conditions. Most importantly, investment amounts are chronically incompatible with the country’s needs and its potential over the years of independence, so they cannot have any impact on the economic recovery and GDP growth. And this phenomenon is no longer dependent on the aggression of the Russian Federation…

On October 11, the President of Ukraine V. Zelensky signed the Law “On Amendments to Certain Legislative Acts of Ukraine on Encouraging Investment Activity in Ukraine” (No. 132-IX, entered into force 17.10.2019) to improve the investment climate. Still, there were similar precedents: the Law “On Amendments to the Tax Code of Ukraine on Improving the Investment Climate in Ukraine” (No. 1797-VIII of 12.12.2016), in which contradictions were found in several months, so it was re-introduced…

The RE: think. Invest in Ukraine investment forum is also widely announced. The event took place in Mariupol on October 29 with the participation of President V. Zelensky and Prime Minister O. Goncharuk. More than 50 representatives of international investment funds and companies, more than 350 guests took part, including businesspersons, government and local authorities, embassies. There also was an exhibition of investment projects… For Ukraine, this was the first international event of this kind.

At the Annual Meeting of the Yalta European Strategy in Kyiv, the President of Ukraine V. Zelensky reassured the guests of the paramount importance of foreign investment for the country and the desire to improve the economic environment for them: “We have a number of projects where I invite foreign business under my personal guarantees and security guarantees. This is energy, infrastructure, and transparent land turnover.”

THE SOURCE OF ALL PROBLEMS

All these good intentions usually come to naught because of many serious obstacles. Without removing them, no initiative, even with guarantees from the authorities, can be effective.

Corruption and, consequently, legal instability, bureaucracy, and often the incompetence of many officials are the main causes of inefficient and even harmful activity of the authorities.

According to 2018 data, Ukraine ranked 138th out of 180 ranks in the CPI and is considered the most corrupt in Europe after the Russian Federation (in 2017, Ukraine was close to Iran, the Gambia and Sierra Leone). According to the IMF report, in 2018, Ukraine was the poorest country in Europe, also ranked last among European countries in terms of official salary.

Representatives of many international organizations and leaders of developed European countries have already hinted that the main deterrent mechanism, not only for investment but also for economic cooperation with Ukraine, is determined precisely by the presence of systemic and large-scale corruption in the country. Criminal business has grown in power; people perceive oligarchy and politics as a whole. This — the presence of business in the executive or legislative branches — is unacceptable for European countries. An interesting fact: according to the Polish weekly digest Wprost, there are no politicians in the top ten richest people of the country…

Corruption and poverty, economic backwardness of the country are two interrelated and interdependent phenomena.

Surely, in these circumstances, it is impossible to speak about the legal justice of the judicial system. Foreign business does not trust it.

Due to incompetence, the mechanisms of doing business in Ukraine are extremely complicated. For example, according to the Doing Business rating, a business spends 327.5 hours a year to complete the entire tax procedure in Ukraine, while the average in Eastern Europe is 214.8, and among other developed countries — 154.9. There is almost a double difference.

Unfortunately, many representatives of the Ukrainian authorities are now inviting foreign capital or business (manufacturers, investors) under “personal guarantees”. It is nonsense. This is a throwback to the imperial times when a nobleman could allow or forbid something. The guarantees should be uniform — legal and legislative. The rest is populism, an attempt to advertise oneself as a patriot who worries about the state. Serious investment has been coming into the country for many years, if not decades. The main condition for the presence of foreign (as well as domestic) business is political, legislative and social stability in the country. It is about forming the economic situation, not by a “guarantor” but the law.

After all, the authorities generously giving out “personal guarantees” today can be dismissed tomorrow, and it is doubtful that the new team will be committed to the protégé of their political opponents. This situation makes businesses entirely dependent on a fast-paced political environment. Only the law equal for everyone and compliance with it can guarantee economic security for investors.

That’s why investors expect not only the legal changes in Ukraine but also improvements of the mechanisms of implementation of legislation, in particular, the proper functioning of the judicial system, the impartiality of the power and control bodies. Most importantly, a conscious and sincere desire of Ukrainian officials to promote the development of their country.

Solving these issues can transform Ukraine, given its potential, into one of the most desirable countries to create a strong financial and economic environment. Only then investments will come from the “impossible” category into the “inevitable” one.

Other articles

  • An analogue of a Turkish drone is expected in Ukroboronprom
    News

    An analogue of a Turkish drone is expected in Ukroboronprom

    The Ukrainian Sokil-300 drone is an analogue of the Turkish Bayraktar and it may join the army next year. The head of Ukroboronprom Igor Fomenko announced it in an interview with RBC-Ukraine. “This is an analogue of the same Turkish Bayraktar. With funding it may already be adopted in a year,” he said. Fomenko says […]

  • The value of bitcoin has approached $ 20 thousand
    News

    The value of bitcoin has approached $ 20 thousand

    Last week, the value of cryptocurrency fell sharply, but now it is approaching a historic high again. According to Coin Desk, after a sharp drop last week, the value of bitcoin broke the record and reached $ 19,686. Thus, the cryptocurrency exceeded the value recorded on December 16, 2017 by $ 20,665. But the absolute […]

  • Poroshenko’s former plant has paid off 300 million in debt
    News

    Poroshenko’s former plant has paid off 300 million in debt

    The Kyiv shipyard Kuznya na Rybalskomu (Ukrainian: “Кузня на Рибальському”) has returned to the state budget more than 300 million UAH, which the Ministry of Finance had previously paid on the company’s debts. It is noted that in 2017 the government provided state guarantees for a plant loan from Ukreximbank. The credit line allowed to […]

  • The tenth distillery was sold at auction in Ukraine
    News

    The tenth distillery was sold at auction in Ukraine

    The State Property Fund sold the Khorostkiv distillery at auction for UAH 55 million. This was reported on the auction page. This is the tenth enterprise in the industry to be privatized. Its initial cost was 31.4 million UAH. It is noted that four buyers participated in the auction for the sale of the Khorostkiv […]

  • Moderna has reported 100% efficiency of the vaccine against severe cases of COVID-19
    News

    Moderna has reported 100% efficiency of the vaccine against severe cases of COVID-19

    Following the third phase of trials of its COVID-19 coronavirus vaccine, Moderna said the drug was generally well tolerated and no serious health problems were identified. According to the company, the effectiveness of its vaccine reaches 94.1%, and 100% for preventing severe coronavirus cases. Previously, the manufacturer estimated the effectiveness of its drug at 94.5%. […]

  • AirBaltic will resume flights to Ukraine
    News

    AirBaltic will resume flights to Ukraine

    Latvian airline AirBaltic will resume flights to Ukraine on December 1 and will start a new flight Vilnius-Kiev to Boryspil airport. The schedule includes departures twice a week on Tuesdays and Saturdays on Airbus A220-300. Flights from Vilnius will depart at 09:00, from Kiev – at 11:15. “Vilnius Airport can be used for transit to […]

  • Eurozone finance ministers have approved the ESM reform
    News

    Eurozone finance ministers have approved the ESM reform

    German Finance Minister Olaf Scholz said that eurozone finance ministers had agreed on a package of measures to reform the European Stabilization Fund (ESM). “The ESM reform strengthens the euro and the entire European banking sector,” said Scholz, whose country currently holds the EU presidency. According to the agreements, a new “safety cushion” for European […]

  • Britain intends to start vaccination against coronavirus in December
    News

    Britain intends to start vaccination against coronavirus in December

    The British government hopes that in the coming weeks the relevant authorities of the country will register two vaccines against coronavirus. Boris Johnson, the Prime Minister announced it in an interview with Sky News on Monday, November 30. “So far, no vaccine has been approved for use by the Medicines and Medical Devices Agency. However, […]

Read also

Investment in Ukraine: inevitable or impossible?
News

Biopharma is going to invest $ 12 million in its development in 2016

In 2015, the company built a plant for the production of probiotics, conducted a reconstruction of the station for a blood transfusion, as well as invested in the development of new drugs. The Pharmaceutical company Biopharma (Kiev region) intends to keep the volume of investments in development at the level of 2015 – $ 12 […]

Next
Investment in Ukraine: inevitable or impossible?
News

State Property Fund in the early spring will repeat the auction for the sale of shares of Kherson CHPP

Almost 100% of the shares (99.83%) of Kherson heat and power plant will be re-auctioned by the State Property Fund of Ukraine. According to preliminary data it will be held on March, 16 of this year on sale with a starting price of 155 million UAH. It is reported by the source Sehodnia.ua. Terms of […]

Next
Investment in Ukraine: inevitable or impossible?
News

Microsoft is going to buy the game developer ZeniMax for $ 7.5 billion

The American information technology giant of Microsoft intends to buy the creator and developer of games ZeniMax Media for $ 7.5 billion. “On Monday, Microsoft announced plans to acquire ZeniMax Media, parent company for Bethesda Softworks, one of the world’s largest private developers and game publishers … Under the terms of the agreement, Microsoft will […]

Next
Investment in Ukraine: inevitable or impossible?
News

Alibaba Group buys South China Morning Post for $ 266 million

The largest Chinese company Alibaba Group announced the acquisition of the largest English-language printed edition in Hong Kong – South China Morning Post (SCMP). The agreement between two large companies estimated at $ 266 million. Representatves of companies told about the agreement on December 14, 2015. All details of the agreement are kept in a […]

Next
Investment in Ukraine: inevitable or impossible?
News

Cosco Pasific is the only contender to purchase the Piraeus Port in Greece

Cosco is the world’s leading container carrier that is the only candidate  to bit for the purchase of 51% stake in the state port of Piraeus in Greece. The  sale will help to generate hundreds million of euros for Greece, which is experiencing significant financial difficulties ,  therefore is engaged in the sale of  State […]

Next
Investment in Ukraine: inevitable or impossible?
News

In Japan reported about cyberattacks on the vaccine developers

Since April of this year, Japanese companies and organizations involved in the development of the vaccines that protect against coronavirus infection, periodically experience cyber-attacks. This was announced on Monday, October 19, by Kyodo news agency, with the reference to the experts of the American company CrowdStrike, engaged in the cybersecurity. According to experts of the […]

Next
Investment in Ukraine: inevitable or impossible?
News

Walmart has partnered with three drone manufacturers launching trial delivery of tests for the coronavirus

The company Walmart continues to follow the advanced technology in the field of e-commerce and delivery. Walmart has partnered with three drone manufacturers: Flytrex, Zipline and DroneUp, as well as with the large American network of clinical laboratories Quest Diagnostics. According to the company, DroneUp drones have already made 57 flights with the average time […]

Next
Investment in Ukraine: inevitable or impossible?
News

Investors against Citigroup

PIMCO and other investors appealed to the court with the case against Citigroup, due to the fact that the bank is not able to control the mortgage loans, resulting in $2.3 billion of losses. Citigroup will respond in a New York´s state court in Manhattan for actions that not justified the confidence of investors. Now […]

Next
Investment in Ukraine: inevitable or impossible?
Analytics

Levelling of a legal profession institute : how do professionals react

On October 7, 2016,  the protest action was organised by Council of lawyers of the Kyiv city  and Lawyers Council of Kiev region took place in Kyiv. Though this action will take place under walls of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine. However, the problems to which lawyers will pay attention, don’t concern people’s deputies. It […]

Next
Investment in Ukraine: inevitable or impossible?
Analytics

Realities and prospects of the real estate market of Ukraine

Ukraine’s real estate market throughout 2017 experienced the impact of both economic and political crisis phenomena, under pressure from the economic downturn and lower purchasing power of the population. Despite all the negative trends, construction statistics in the period 2017 recorded positive results, which are confirmed by such an authoritative world ranking of Doing Business […]

Next
Investment in Ukraine: inevitable or impossible?
News

“Agroprosperis” invested about $ 50 million in the elevator business

During the past 5 years was invested about $ 10 million per year in the construction and modernization of the elevators of “Agroprosperis”. This was told by the CEO of the NCH Agribusiness Investment Fund – “Agroprosperis” Group of companies, Igor Osmachko in an interview to the Liga.Business. “For the moment, the structure of the […]

Next
Investment in Ukraine: inevitable or impossible?
News

Chinese and Ukrainian companies will build a wind farm

The Chinese company POWERCHINA and the Ukrainian company WindFarm have signed a contract for the joint construction of a wind farm in the Donetsk region. This was reported by the press service of WindFarm. “The cost of the project is at least $ 1 billion, which makes it the largest wind energy project in Ukraine,” […]

Next
Investment in Ukraine: inevitable or impossible?
News

Cargill investment project for $ 100 million is blocked

The investment project of the company with US capital Cargill of about $ 90-100 million is blocked. Alexander Kramarenko, the chief editor of the “Money” magazine, told about this in his blog “By what Ukraine scares foreign investors”. “Delta Bank and Cargill”. Cargill is an agricultural business with a century and a half of history, […]

Next
Investment in Ukraine: inevitable or impossible?
News

“GSK” and “Vir Biotechnology” go to phase of the 3 studies of antibodies against COVID-19

Companies Vir Biotechnology, Inc. and GlaxoSmithKline plc (GSK) announced the global extension to phase 3 of the COMET-ICE study, which evaluates the effectiveness of monoclonal antibodies – VIR-7831 for early treatment of COVID-19 in patients at high risk of hospitalization. VIR-7831 (also known as GSK4182136) is the fully human monoclonal antibody against SARS-CoV-2, selected for […]

Next
Investment in Ukraine: inevitable or impossible?
News

Association of telecom providers USTelecom will appear in federal court in the case of “net neutrality”

The Major Trade Organization USTelecom, which represents the telecommunication companies in the United States, will speak at the court with a lawsuit, demanding for releasing it from the new “net neutrality” rules in the Internet. The new rules of the FCC equate Internet to conventional telecommunication channels and oblige providers equally apply to any traffic […]

Next
Investment in Ukraine: inevitable or impossible?
News

Teva received the permission from the Antimonopoly Committee to deal with the Allergan

The Teva Ukraine company is the part of the Teva Corporation, the  leading international pharmaceutical company specializing in the development, manufacture and marketing of generic and original medicines. The Antimonopoly Committee of Ukraine gave the permission for concerted action in the form of fulfillment of the conditions contained in Articles 9.6 and 9.12 of the […]

Next
WP2Social Auto Publish Powered By : XYZScripts.com